Start a Conversation

Unsolved

T

1 Rookie

 • 

2 Posts

48

December 18th, 2024 21:23

XPS 15 9520 RAID 1

XPS 15 9520

XPS 15 9520

I have an XPS 15 9520 that had a single drive when received from Dell.  The settings in BIOS were with the RAID enabled, everything worked fine.

The the hard drive died, as a precaution the single drive has been replaced by a pair of Crucial P310 drives which I have configured as RAID 1 (mirror).  I initially did this through the BIOS - or at least the tool you access from the F12/BIOS area.  When complete I noticed the performance was pretty poor.  I check an identical 9520 (we have 8) that had the single original drive (configured again as RAID from factory - all 8 machine are), and performance was less than half.

I then undid the RAID set up using the Intel tool in Windows (no BIOS changes) and tested and a single Crucial drive marginally out performs the original drive in the other machine.  Confused, I recreated the RAID 1 using the Intel tool in Windows, rebooted and tested again, and once more the performance is less than half of a single drive.

All updates BIOS and OS (Windows 11) are applied, so what's the story?  How are you meant to do this, because a RAID setup that slashes performance by that much isn't worth having!

Tom

10 Elder

 • 

28.7K Posts

December 18th, 2024 21:57

It's not a surprise, since the data has to be written to two drives -- and this isn't true hardware RAID.  

1 Rookie

 • 

2 Posts

December 18th, 2024 22:15

@ejn63​ 

Thanks for your quick reply, I didn't realise that it was solely software based and that writing the same thing to 2 drives on different channels would take twice as long.

I've got a spare drive now!

(edited)

No Events found!

Top