Start a Conversation

Unsolved

This post is more than 5 years old

2517

March 29th, 2012 11:00

What advice would you give EMC customers looking for improved performance and/or big data analytic warehouses considering SAP HANA?

SAP’s HANA combines compute, memory, compression, columnar indexing, non-disruptive updates, parallel processing, and advanced Intel chip functionality.  That combined with SAP Business Objects and Mobility makes for a compelling business case for a one stop provider that only gets better as memory prices plummet and clustering increases in-memory scalability. 

SAP and EMC customers are asking compelling questions and looking for guidance.  What advice would you provide to answer these questions?

  1. Is the in-memory market stable enough to jump in for any of the major vendors?
  2. Besides SAP HANA, Exadata, Teradata, Netezza, and Greenplum, are there other vendors that can do high performance analytics?
  3. Should I wait for HANA to mature if I have the luxury and if so until when?
  4. If I decide I need the analytical performance now what are the best criteria for picking a vendor?
  5. What questions should I ask each vendor?           
  6. What are the strengths and weaknesses of each solution from storage only analytics to all memory and everything in between?
  7. What are the key differences between HANA, Exadata, Teradata, Netezza, and Greenplum?
  8. Does one solution handle unstructured better than another?
  9. Are any of these solutions better for a true cloud solution including mobility from cloud to cloud?
  10. Do these products address true data integration and archive retrieval?
  11. How can EMC best become an in-memory appliance player no matter what the customer chooses?

8 Posts

April 4th, 2012 08:00

From: Lavallee, John
Sent: Wednesday, April 04, 2012 10:59 AM
To: Stone, Allan
Subject: RE: ECN Discussion Any comments?

Hello Allan,
Did you get any answers?

I have asked the same question a few times and got some good answers.

Once during a SAP eco-system call focused on HANA (a good while ago, organized by James Franklin)

And more recently when I attended an EBC in Hopkinton at a Greenplum meeting with George Radford, Field CTO.

I'd recommend that you contact George.

In summary:

They are not actually competing with each other currently.

Those going with the "appliance" (HANA) are focused on acceleration SAP reports in a specific SAP location. 

The play here is relatively simple – plug/play from an installation and professional services offering.

HANA pulls from the SAP instances / data and accelerates reporting.

Those interested in using GP are pulling together SAP + other diverse data sources to create a different kind of pool to have a "bigger picture". 

It's a larger play (from a ETL perspective, NOT from a cost perspective) with a different kind of Professional Services engagement but also a different result – larger/more powerful yet a very different engagement.

Regards

John

John Lavallée Partner Technology Consultant - Focus Partners EMEA

EMC Deutschland GmbH

Mobile:      +49-163-6895020

No Events found!

Top